Guy’s American Bar is in Times Square, but its Kitchen must be in a distant suburb of Flavortown…

(Originally written January 23, 2013)

What trip to New York City would be complete without a visit to celebrity chef Guy Fieri’s Times Square joint, which received such a glowing review in the Times?  As a big fan of Diners, Drive-Ins and Dives (the show, not the fat fuck who hosts it), I of course had to come check it out.  Were the Awesome Pretzel Chicken Tenders really not so awesome?  Did the watermelon margarita really taste like formaldehyde?  My life would not be complete without the answers to these questions.  But, much to my dismay, I see they’ve omitted the formaldehyde martini.  The chicken tenders, on the other hand, are very much still a menu item:

awesome_chicken_tenders

Now, I will agree with NYT food critic Pete Wells in that I would’ve never guessed that the breading contains either pretzels or smoked almonds.  That said, they really weren’t that bad.  Big, hot and crispy…  Better (and more expensive) than the chicken fingers I buy at Costco, that’s for sure!  Also, the Donkey Sauce really added an extra kick.  At least, I think that’s what it was called.  It was really just a spicy mustard.  Anyways, while the tenders were at least partially awesome, I can’t exactly say the same about the pulled pork tacos…

pulled_pork_tacos

Now, while the pork itself had the right amount of tang, it wasn’t even remotely warm.  And the random sprinkling of corn, cheese and semen-lookalike white sauce didn’t really add much of an extra kick.  This dish does not reside in Flavourtown, put it that way!

Alas, while there were initial reports of the place being packed, it was half-empty when I arrived around noon on a Sunday.  And yet, even though there were only three people sitting at the downstairs bar, the food-runner still managed to give my grub to the other folks–before he was chastised by the barkeep.  Granted, it might seem weird for one person to order two appetizers, but man, their mains were fucking expensive!

On the plus side, I take some comfort in knowing that the cooks all washed their hands before preparing my pork tacos.  I’m assuming they read the sign, anyways…

must_wash_hands

Advertisements

11 thoughts on “Guy’s American Bar is in Times Square, but its Kitchen must be in a distant suburb of Flavortown…

  1. Pingback: Guy Fieri’s Buffalo NY Wing Sauce brings Buffalo north of the border | Gruesome Chews

  2. Pingback: John Catucci is a true Canadian treasure! | Gruesome Chews

  3. Pingback: Top 5 Food Cities: 4. New York City | Gruesome Chews

  4. Pingback: Top 5 Food Cities: 4. New York City | Gruesome Chews

  5. Pingback: Best burger in NYC? Let’s break it down… | Gruesome Chews

  6. Pingback: Eating Las Vegas | Gruesome Chews

  7. Pingback: Eating Las Vegas | Burgers, Bacon & Beer

  8. Pingback: Best burger in NYC? Let’s break it down… | Burgers, Bacon & Beer

  9. Pingback: Top 5 Food Cities: 4. New York City | Burgers, Bacon & Beer

  10. Pingback: John Catucci is a true Canadian treasure! | Burgers, Bacon & Beer

  11. Pingback: Guy Fieri’s Buffalo NY Wing Sauce brings Buffalo north of the border | Burgers, Bacon & Beer

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s